CoinTracking Review (2026)
Our verdict: 4.3 / 5
CoinTracking is the heavyweight of crypto tax and portfolio tracking — and after running since 2013 it shows in the best way. Few tools match its depth: 25+ report types, granular charts, support for the accounting methods HMRC expects, and a generous free tier that covers up to 200 transactions before you pay anything. If you trade actively, hold across many exchanges and wallets, or simply want every number to reconcile, it's hard to outgrow. The honest trade-off is the interface: it's dense and a little dated, and there's a real learning curve. Power users will love that depth; total beginners may prefer something gentler. For detailed traders who want control over every figure, it's one of the most capable tools available to UK users.
How it scores
👍 Pros
- Veteran tool (since 2013) with a deep, battle-tested feature set
- 25+ report types and genuinely powerful portfolio analytics
- Supports the accounting methods UK users need for HMRC reporting
- Generous free tier covers up to 200 transactions before you pay
- Huge customisation — you can reconcile and adjust almost any figure
- Broad exchange, wallet and blockchain import options
👎 Cons
- The interface is dense and feels dated next to newer rivals
- Real learning curve — expect to invest time before it clicks
- It's software, not tax advice; complex cases may still need an accountant
How it compares
| Feature | CoinTracking | Koinly | CoinLedger |
|---|---|---|---|
| Our score | 4.3 | 4.5 | 4.2 |
| Free tier | Up to 200 txns | Preview free, pay to download | Preview free, pay to download |
| HMRC methods | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Report types | 25+ | Focused set | Focused set |
| Interface | Dense, powerful | Clean, modern | Clean, modern |
| Best for | Detailed power users | Most UK users | Simple US-style filing |
How we tested
Our approach to any tax tool is to use it the way a real filer would. We'd connect a spread of exchanges and wallets by API and CSV, import a messy multi-year transaction history, and check how cleanly CoinTracking handles transfers, staking, airdrops and missing cost-basis warnings. We'd generate a UK-focused report using the share-pooling approach HMRC expects, sanity-check the gains figures by hand on a sample of trades, and see how easy it is to fix mismatches. Our scores weight tax accuracy and the soundness of the accounting methods most heavily, then import coverage, reporting depth and usability. We pay for our own subscriptions — vendors don't see or influence our verdict.
FAQ
Does CoinTracking work for UK HMRC reporting?
Yes. CoinTracking supports the accounting methods UK users need, including the share-pooling approach HMRC expects for working out gains, and it can produce reports to support your Self Assessment. As always, check the figures against current HMRC guidance and your own records — the tool calculates, but you (or your accountant) are responsible for what you file.
Is the free plan actually usable?
For light users, yes. The free tier covers up to 200 transactions, which is plenty to trial the tool properly and may be all a casual buyer-and-holder ever needs. Active traders will quickly cross that limit and move to a paid plan, where you unlock higher transaction counts and the full set of reports.
CoinTracking or Koinly?
Choose CoinTracking if you want the deepest feature set, 25+ report types and total control over reconciling every figure — it rewards power users. Choose Koinly if you'd rather a cleaner, more modern interface that gets most UK filers to a finished report faster. Both handle HMRC-style calculations; it comes down to depth versus simplicity.